breaking news
  • Manifesto Manthan: Does Congress’ Poll Promises Institutionalise Legal Discrimination Against Hindus?
  • Judge approves $418 million damages for home sellers overcharged by Realtors
  • Welcome to Another ‘American Century.’ Set aside the election and hot wars. How the U.S. resolves its crisis of confidence is what’ll shape the world.
  • Taiwan: 9 Dead, Buildings Tilt, Bridges & Cars Shake In Island's Strongest Earthquake In 25 Yrs
  • Amit Shah to campaign in five TN LS constituencies on Thursday
  • Special module to prepare kids for formal education in UP

View Details

The South Asian Insider

Xi Jinping must not push his G20 luck too far. His worst India-US nightmares can come true



Russian President Vladimir Putin isn't coming to India for the G20 summit, US President Joe Biden is ignoring the East Asia Summit in favour of India and Vietnam, and China has put out a map that includes Arunachal Pradesh as well as Aksai Chin as part of its territory. Welcome to the world, it just got a bit more complicated this week.
As he winds down from his second term as prime minister, Narendra Modi is getting a feel for the games big nations play as well as the people who play them. Mapping Biden, Putin, Xi at G20
Let's start with the US president. Biden may be 80 years old, but he and his administration have decided that they will do everything in their capacity to cut China down to size - and if that means supporting India, a country one-fifth of China's economy but still the only nation with the potential to take on Beijing, then so be it.
Meanwhile, Russia's Putin seems to have opted out of international fora like BRICS and G20 almost entirely - which is a real pity, because if there is one country in the world that would have feted the Russian president at a time when he is consumed with more than one severe crisis, it is India. Notwithstanding Delhi's growing proximity to the US, India has been in so many trouble spots in the past decades that it understands the value of old friendships that don't disappear with the next fashion wave.
Putin's absence at the G20 also makes it easier for Delhi to resolve such weighty matters as where to seat which leader at the summit meetings as well as over lunch and dinner. So, first things first. What's the shape of the table around which the world's high and mighty are going to rest their elbows? Is it going to be square, rectangular, or round?
None of the above. I can confirm that all formal conversations will be held around an oval table - with Modi at the head of one gentle curve. With the Russian president not coming, the protocol section of the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) is almost smiling - now, one only has to figure out how not to have Biden and Xi chat together for too long.
Even the photo-op becomes easier to handle. Russia's foreign minister Sergey Lavrov, probably the most astute diplomat in the world, clearly isn't as frightening - or as interesting - as Putin. With Lavrov standing in for his president, the G20 photo-op just became a breezy cake-walk.
Then there is the avuncular Xi, who agreed with Modi in South Africa less than a week ago that both leaders will order their officials to de-escalate the three-year-old face-off in Ladakh. Aha, exulted India. Xi well understands the Asian value of saving face, which means that he isn't going to rock the boat until at least India's G20 summit, which means that he and Modi can shake hands, embrace each other and laugh heartily at the cameras.
Mere days later, on Tuesday, China's ministry of natural resources published a map that showed - again - Arunachal Pradesh as part of China. Clearly, Xi believes that the Asian value of saving face only applies to big powers like China - smaller nations like India need not bother.
But Xi must also know that two can play this game. Just because India has not liked to publicise the fact that Indian patrols cannot patrol large parts of Depsang anymore because they are stopped from doing so by Chinese patrols, doesn't mean that India is going to roll over and allow China to occupy even more territory than it has on the map.
Can Modi twist China's tail?
That's where the US comes in. It suits India well to project its power - with a little bit of help from the Americans. Evidently, the partnership is going really well. From intelligence-gathering to potential interdiction on the Indian Ocean, Xi must know that his worst India-US nightmares can also come true.
Worse, Modi seems to be stealing Xi's lines on becoming the favourite country of the "Global South". The plan to export to at least 50 fellow poor nations the JAM trinity ideas - from Jan Dhan accounts to Aadhar to Mobile-based transactions, which have been such a game-changer at home - has sent a frisson of excitement coursing through the neighbourhood.
Modi's boys - from S Jaishankar to Piyush Goyal to Ashwini Vaishnaw to Dharmendra Pradhan - also seem determined to rewrite some of the RSS-inspired malthink that passes off as swadeshi pride, for example the recent fatwa on banning the import of computers. Modi's ministers understand that such a silly directive can have a hugely dampening effect on western business trying to make in India. Especially with India trying to diversify the value chain that begins and ends with China, cutting your nose to spite your manufacturing face isn't going to cut it, post-G20, summit or no summit.
Modi as well as the rest of the world know that Western business continues to salivate to make in China - whatever the geopolitics amounts to. That's why India has to desperately attract some big ticket investments on the lines of Apple's intentions. Certainly, the sooner the Modi govt gets rid of some of these anti-commonsense measures, the better it might be able to win the propaganda war.
As for the G20, Modi has made sure that India is putting its best foot forward - I mean, even some Miss World beauties are being feted in post-Article 370 Srinagar. And whatever happens on the domestic politics front henceforth, Modi knows that the joust with China has entered a new chapter.